Today is the ninth session of Jakarta Governor Basuki “Ahok” Tjahaja Purnama’s blasphemy trial. One of the issues that Ahok and his lawyers have brought up throughout the trial is that all of the people who filed criminal blasphemy reports (such as Islamic Defenders Front leaders Habib Rizieq and Habib Novel) with the police over a speech that the governor gave to citizens on Pulau Seribu’s Pramuka Island in September had not actually watched the speech in person.
Well, one of the witnesses called by the prosecution today was a fisherman from Pulau Seribu named Sahbudin, nicknamed Deni, who was actually in the audience during Ahok’s infamous speech in which he said that some politicians were using a verse from the Qu’ran, Al-Maidah 51, to trick people into not voting for him.
But it seems quite clear from his testimony that Deni had not exactly been coached by the prosecution to say what they needed him to say to make their case. In fact, Deni said he couldn’t even recall Ahok’s reference to the Qu’ran in his speech.
“I’m still trying to remember whether the al-Maida [incident] did take place. I was not paying attention. The women [there] were very loud, they also cheered,” Deni said said while giving his testimony, as quoted by Tempo.
Deni said he did remember certain parts of his Ahok’s speech, including a profit sharing scheme for island residents and a promise of a more affordable food staple market in Pulau Seribu.
“I also heard the sentence ‘If you think other candidates are better, don’t vote for me [Ahok].’ I did not pay attention to other [remarks],” Deni said.
However, Deni did say he heard about Ahok’s alleged blasphemy some time later, when a friend showed him the edited, viral video of the governor’s speech posted on social media by Buni Yani (who has been named a suspect by the police for spreading hate speech).
Deni said that, as a Muslim, he was disappointed to hear of Ahok’s referencing of the Quranic verse since he was a Chinese-Christian.
The judge then asked Deni if he knew what Al-Maidah 51 actually says. The Pulau Seribu resident admitted that he did not know exactly, but he had heard a speech by celebrity cleric AA Gym saying that Ahok had committed blasphemy, which to him proved that the governor was wrong and needed to apologize.
Previously, Ahok and his lawyers have questioned how the governor could’ve committed blasphemy during his speech if none in the people in the audience, who were almost all Muslims, expressed any anger at the time.
As Abdi, another resident of Pulau Seribu who spoke in Ahok’s defense at the governor’s campaign HQ in Menteng, said: “If [Ahok] had insulted my religion, [FPI leader Habib Rizieq] wouldn’t have needed to report him, I would have stabbed Pak Ahok right there.”
